Election myth-buster

Does it matter who wins? Less than you think.

Six things everyone “knows” about politics and the stock market, checked against the actual numbers. Spoiler: the Fed, earnings and the economy usually matter more than the party in charge.

19 / 19midterms followed by a higher market a year later
~5 ptsgap between parties, on average
~11 ptsgap between Fed cutting and hiking years

The verdicts

Six myths, on trial

“Stocks do better under Democratic presidents.”

Misleading

On average, yes: about +13.8% a year under Democratic presidents vs. +8.5% under Republicans (S&P 500, 1953–2025). But the gap inside each party is bigger than the gap between them. A Republican president with a Republican Congress (+13.3%) beat a fully Democratic Washington (+8.0%).

Evidence: 6 president–Congress setups, 1953–2025 (RBC Wealth Management / Bloomberg)

“A midterm shake-up is bad for stocks.”

False

In all 19 midterm elections since 1950, the S&P 500 was higher 12 months later, with an average gain of about 15%, whichever party won. Getting the uncertainty out of the way mattered more than the result.

Evidence: 19 of 19 midterms, 1950–2022

“Gridlock is good for stocks.”

It depends

Divided government produced the best setup (a Democratic president with a split Congress, +17.0% a year) and the worst (a Republican president facing a Democratic Congress, +4.9%). Gridlock itself isn’t the driver; the economy a president inherits matters more.

Evidence: 6 president–Congress setups, 1953–2025

“Which party is in power matters more than the Fed.”

False

The S&P 500 rose in 8 of 12 years when the Fed was cutting rates (average +8.1%) but only 4 of 11 years when it was hiking (average −3.1%). That gap of about 11 points is twice the party gap of about 5.

Evidence: 23 years tagged by Fed direction, 1973–2024

“High inflation always sinks stocks.”

Not always

Of 9 high-inflation or stagflation years, the market still rose in 4, including 2021 (+26.9%) and 1980 (+25.8%). The typical year was roughly flat. Hard, but not hopeless.

Evidence: 9 inflation-tagged years, 1973–2024

“A recession means a losing year for stocks.”

Coin flip

Of 12 recession years, 6 still ended higher, led by 1975 (+31.5%) and 1980 (+25.8%). Markets often bottom before the economy does, so waiting for the all-clear can mean missing the rebound.

Evidence: 12 recession-tagged years, 1973–2024

All six setups, ranked

S&P 500 average yearly return by who runs Washington

Dem president · split Congress+17.0%
Dem president · Rep Congress+16.3%
Rep president · Rep Congress+13.3%
Dem president · Dem Congress+8.0%
Rep president · split Congress+7.3%
Rep president · Dem Congress+4.9%

Every setup was positive on average. The best and worst are both “divided government”, which is why gridlock alone explains little. Source: RBC Wealth Management / Bloomberg, S&P 500 price returns, 1953–2025 (dividends excluded).

The cost of sitting out

$10,000 in the Dow, 1900–2020

$4.2MStayed invested the whole time
~$430KInvested only under Democratic presidents
~$99KInvested only under Republican presidents

Pulling out when “your” side loses has been far more expensive than either party. Source: Schwab / Ned Davis Research, Dow Jones Industrial Average, 1900–2020.

What actually moves your stocks

Watch the calendar, not the campaign.

Earnings reports, Fed decisions and the economy move individual stocks far more than elections do. Capmark puts those dates, and how big each one usually is, on one screen.

Averages hide wide year-to-year swings, and past returns don’t predict future ones. Fed, inflation and recession tags follow Capmark’s classic dataset (1973–2024); see the methodology. Education, not investment advice.